Review: Assassin's Creed II Battle of Forli DLC
Assuming those of you reading this review have already hopped, skipped and stabbed your way through Assassin’s Creed II, I ask you this: do you remember when Animus techie Rebecca Crane desynchronised Desmond Miles from Ezio in chapter 11, explaining the Animus data had become corrupt, before throwing you into chapter 14 sporting some fashionable face fuzz? What became of chapters 12 and 13?
Truth is these two 'corrupted memory sequences' were actually omitted from the final game by Ubisoft in order to meet the November 20th launch deadline. Conveniently, it made good business sense to release these missing segments later under the category of ‘DLC’. That’s right; Battle of Forli is missing chapter 12 of Ezio’s adventure which, as you might expect, slots seamlessly into the established narrative and throws in a few interesting twists for good measure. But is the content worth the florins?
Rather than refine, build on or improve upon the title’s mechanics this add-on exists merely to fill a gap, and gives us good reason to reacquaint ourselves with our nimble death-dealing Italian. Continuing from where chapter 11 left off, BoF reintroduces the mysterious Caterina Sforza whom Ezio first encountered on his way to Venice. All is well until her citadel Rocca di Ravaldino is attacked by the boisterous Orsi brothers, two Templars who wreak havoc to create a diversion that will allow them to make off with the Apple of Eden. Over Ezio’s dead body...
Without giving too much away, this DLC delivers six challenging new memories incorporating a nice mix of frantic skirmishes, escort missions, assassinations and fast-paced street chases. The good news is that the entire experience is quite gratifying. The bad news is that it is disappointingly short-lived. If you’re a fairly apt assassin like me, it’ll take you no more than sixty minutes to reach the chapter’s rather anti-climatic conclusion, and you’ll soon be back to aimlessly bullying guards and shoving archers off rooftops just for something to do.
Furthermore, BoF provides little actual reward value. Personally, I was expecting a bit more substance in the way of another catacomb to explore, a new skill or two to learn, some new blades to wield, or perhaps the odd trophy to earn, but sadly my expectations were not met. You do get to unlock a ‘special memory’ which lets you soar the skies in Leonardo da Vinci’s flying machine any time you like, but after you’ve done it once or twice the novelty begins to ebb away.
Paying $3.99 (or £3.19) for an hour’s worth of entertainment is definitely a judgement call. No doubt OCD suffers will purchase the content without hesitation simply to complete the main story, and that’s absolutely understandable. However, my recommendation would be to wait until March when Ubisoft’s second batch of DLC, Bonfire of the Vanities, is released. Buy the two together and play chapters 12 and 13 back-to-back, because though BoF is enjoyable it is by itself undersized and forgettable.
6/10




Comments
I too downloaded the DLC and thought it could've been longer, but at the same time I wonder if can we actually review Battle of Forli as DLC. Sequences 12 and 13 were cut from the original game due to time constraints, so should we be surprised they add nothing new? And should we have to pay for them at all, given they should've been in the original game to begin with? I don't know...
Anyway, thanks for your thoughts. Another good review.
Yeah, I hear ya... I wasn't trying to make an "attack".. maybe more or less a defense. Nowadays, anything under $5 bucks is considered a good deal.. since most of us aren't recession proof any little bit of chump change to help us get our gaming fix (especially on an acclaimed title) is worth the purchase… heck I even waste money on LBP costumes to this day…And I’ve only popped in LBP once or twice after the MGS Costumes and Levels were released. But you’re right, reveiws are just opinions, I personally think that DLC in particular is pretty tough to review… there’s no standard price for comparison, they’re usually pretty unique even though, 90% of them are just aesthetic and add no additional gameplay experience, out of that 90%, 85% are usually half ass-edly put together. I just feel that Ubisoft deserves credit for making an attempt to extend and prolong the gameplay of what some would consider GOTY 09…though obviously Uncharted 2 took the cake. To be honest, I havent had a chance to DL the Battle of Forli quite yet, and whose to say.. I may feel the same as you. But to be honest after playing Assassins Creed I … I walked into ACII feeling like it would be a chore to finish the game. After seeing how they actually listened to reviews, and changed what we consumers loathed about the game, I think they deserve some credit on taking that extra step to add 2 DLC episodes. I’m usually not a big fan of MultiPlat games, but Ubisoft does exceptionally well with their titles. Ok, my rant is over, sorry again for the attack, I just think there’s a lot more [or less] to constraints when it comes to reviewing DLC. Again, this was a good read!
Nothing was said about the DLC being bad Jared, just that it was short and lacking in new things.
Your attack is a bit OTT in my opinion. Ok, so the DLC has been critised for its length, but the closing recommendation made was 'buy it later', not 'don't buy it'. Also, I do believe I read the words 'enjoyable' and 'gratifying' in there somewhere.
Harsh or not, I'd rather have someone tell me their honest opinion, even if it's not what I want to hear (after all, reviews are just opinions).
If you did the math... 3.99/1 hr.. is the equivalent 59.99/ 15hr.. so why is everyone complaining? Most campaigns dont even stretch 15 hours. Not to mention, 90% of the DLC that gets dished out for nearly the same price does not as harsh reviews as this. No one reviews LBP costumes and some are just a dollar cheaper than what this packs with it. And they don't even add any extra gameplay. I really think reviewers are being too harsh on this content. I dont know the reasoning for having these 2 DLC additions to Assassin's Creed II, but if it has to do with the limited amount of space on an HD-DVD vs Blu Ray, us consumer's should be happy to get the OPTION to have it, as most developers would have cut the content out due to space restraints, and it would never been heard of again. Again, maybe you (not just you, but all reviewers) should realize what it takes to deliver DLC...and not just about what it DOESN'T come with. This isn't just some cheap skins, or stickers. It's a mechanic that extends the gameplay just a little bit longer..and to receive an additional 1hr HD experience for the price of 4 McDoubles.. hell... atleast you'll be sticking to your new years resolutions and passing up on fast food.
Thanks for this review - I got AC2 literally 3 days ago (a belated birthday present from a friend) and I was contemplating getting this, but your summary has helped me to decide NOT to fork out for it, I'm a trophy whore and I'm not paying extra unless it gets trophies! :p
Post new comment